Date Published: March 13, 2019
Publisher: Public Library of Science
Author(s): Neil Anders, Kirsten Howarth, Bjørn Totland, Nils Olav Handegard, Maria Tenningen, Michael Breen, Antonio Medina Guerrero.
Stress to fish during harvest in wild capture fisheries is known to negatively influence subsequent survival in catches that are released. Therefore, if fisheries are to be conducted sustainably, there is a need to promote good fish welfare during the capture process. Purse seine fishing is a widespread and efficient fishing method. However, capture and release of fish from purse seines (a process called “slipping”) can result in extremely high mortality in small pelagic schooling species. The objective of this study was to establish behavioural indicators of sub-lethal stress in Atlantic mackerel (Scomber scombrus) that may be used to set safe threshold limits for use in commercial purse seine fishing, in order to ensure good fish welfare and thereby minimise slipping mortality. Controlled mesocosm scale experiments with schools of mackerel in net pens were undertaken to determine behavioural responses to simulated purse seine capture stressors of “crowding”, “hypoxia” and “crowding & hypoxia”. Crowding (at 30 kg.m-3) was achieved by reducing the volume of the net pen, while hypoxia (to 40% oxygen saturation) was achieved by surrounding the net pen with a tarpaulin bag to prevent water exchange. Using video analysis, we investigated behavioural responses in nearest neighbour distances, nearest neighbour angular deviations, tail beat amplitude and tail beat frequency (TBF). Of the metrics considered, only TBF showed a response; a significant increase to “crowding” (42% increase) and “crowding & hypoxia” (38% increase) was found. The increase in TBF in response to “hypoxia” alone (29% increase) was not significant. We therefore conclude that increases in tail beat frequency may be used as an indicator of sub-lethal purse seine capture stress in mackerel that may have utility in minimising post slipping mortality.
Stress prior to the escape, release or slaughter of wild fish caught by fishing gear has been shown to reduce subsequent fitness , survival [2–4] and resulting product quality [5–9]. Therefore, the minimisation of stress to promote good fish welfare during capture should be of paramount concern for ethical, sustainable and profitable wild capture fisheries.
In order to develop ways of monitoring welfare in commercial purse seine fishing, this study examined several behavioural metrics in individual mackerel in response to sub-lethal levels of capture stress. For the hypoxia treatment, no response in nearest neighbour distance (NND), angular deviation in pitch (ADP) or angular deviation in yaw (ADY) could be detected and likewise we detected no response in tail beat amplitude (TBA) to either “crowding” or “crowding and hypoxia” treatments. However, tail beat frequency (TBF) showed a significant increase in response to the “crowding” and “crowding and hypoxia” treatments; “hypoxia” alone showed an increased but non-significant effect. Previous studies regarding the reaction of mackerel to stress have examined physiological stress responses [80,81], while others have focused solely on mortality outcomes [22,23]. The results presented here are the first to detail individual-level behavioural responses to stress in relatively large groups of mackerel.