Research Article: Empirical relationships between tree fall and landscape-level amounts of logging and fire

Date Published: February 23, 2018

Publisher: Public Library of Science

Author(s): David B. Lindenmayer, Wade Blanchard, David Blair, Lachlan McBurney, John Stein, Sam C. Banks, RunGuo Zang.


Large old trees are critically important keystone structures in forest ecosystems globally. Populations of these trees are also in rapid decline in many forest ecosystems, making it important to quantify the factors that influence their dynamics at different spatial scales. Large old trees often occur in forest landscapes also subject to fire and logging. However, the effects on the risk of collapse of large old trees of the amount of logging and fire in the surrounding landscape are not well understood. Using an 18-year study in the Mountain Ash (Eucalyptus regnans) forests of the Central Highlands of Victoria, we quantify relationships between the probability of collapse of large old hollow-bearing trees at a site and the amount of logging and the amount of fire in the surrounding landscape. We found the probability of collapse increased with an increasing amount of logged forest in the surrounding landscape. It also increased with a greater amount of burned area in the surrounding landscape, particularly for trees in highly advanced stages of decay. The most likely explanation for elevated tree fall with an increasing amount of logged or burned areas in the surrounding landscape is change in wind movement patterns associated with cutblocks or burned areas. Previous studies show that large old hollow-bearing trees are already at high risk of collapse in our study area. New analyses presented here indicate that additional logging operations in the surrounding landscape will further elevate that risk. Current logging prescriptions require the protection of large old hollow-bearing trees on cutblocks. We suggest that efforts to reduce the probability of collapse of large old hollow-bearing trees on unlogged sites will demand careful landscape planning to limit the amount of timber harvesting in the surrounding landscape.

Partial Text

Large old trees are critical elements of stand structural complexity (sensu [1]) in forests worldwide [2–4]. They play an array of key ecological roles ranging from storing disproportionately large amounts of carbon to acting as sources of flowers, pollen and seeds, and providing habitat for numerous elements of the biota (reviewed by [3]).

We recorded 737 hollow-bearing Mountain Ash trees on our 104 field sites. The number of hollow-bearing trees per site ranged from 1 to 23 with a mean of 7.1 per site. Our initial sample of trees in 1997 contained no collapsed trees (Form 9) (Table 1). By 2015, 41% of large old hollow-bearing trees standing in 1997 had collapsed.

Understanding the effects of landscape-level disturbance on keystone structures such as large old hollow-bearing trees is a critical part of forest management given that the amount of natural and human disturbance of forest landscapes is increasing [16] and populations of large of trees are declining in many forest ecosystems globally [3,42].




0 0 vote
Article Rating
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments