Research Article: The epidemic potential of avian influenza A (H7N9) virus in humans in mainland China: A two-stage risk analysis

Date Published: April 19, 2019

Publisher: Public Library of Science

Author(s): Xuzheng Shan, Shengjie Lai, Hongxiu Liao, Zhongjie Li, Yajia Lan, Weizhong Yang, Alessandro Rizzo.


From 2013 to 2017, more than one thousand avian influenza A (H7N9) confirmed cases with hundreds of deaths were reported in mainland China. To identify priorities for epidemic prevention and control, a risk assessing framework for subnational variations is needed to define the epidemic potential of A (H7N9).

We established a consolidated two-stage framework that outlined the potential epidemic of H7N9 in humans: The Stage 1, index-case potential, used a Boosted Regression Trees model to assess population at risk due to spillover from poultry; the Stage 2, epidemic potential, synthesized the variables upon a framework of the Index for Risk Management to measure epidemic potential based on the probability of hazards and exposure, the vulnerability and coping capacity.

Provinces in southern and eastern China, especially Jiangsu, Zhejiang, Guangzhou, have high index-case potential of human infected with A (H7N9), while northern coastal provinces and municipalities with low morbidity, i.e. Tianjin and Liaoning, have an increasing risk of A (H7N9) infection. Provinces in central China are likely to have high potential of epidemic due to the high vulnerability and the lack of coping capacity.

This study provides a unified risk assessment of A (H7N9) to detect the two-stage heterogeneity of epidemic potential among different provinces in mainland China, allowing proactively evaluate health preparedness at subnational levels to improve surveillance, diagnostic capabilities, and health promotion.

Partial Text

The avian influenza A (H7N9) virus infections in humans since 2013 in mainland China are unprecedented both in terms of mortality and morbidity, and the extent to which the disease spread has enlarged in the wave of 2016–17 [1–3]. Previous closely monitoring of virological and molecular characteristics of A (H7N9) virus in poultry and human beings emphasizes that A (H7N9) continues to emerge and spread into populations at risk [4–9]. Therefore, the risk assessment of A (H7N9) in humans is crucial for the preparedness and response of sporadic infections, epidemic, and even potential pandemic.

Based on a two-stage risk assessment framework by integrating BRT model and INFORM models, we demonstrated the locations with index-case potential and epidemic potential of human infected with avian influenza A (H7N9) virus in China. Some coastal provinces or municipalities, such as Tianjin, Liaoning, with lower former morbidity had the spillover risk, while provinces in central China had higher epidemic potential once the index case happened. According to the risk highlighted in this study, strengthening the surveillance, diagnosis capacity, and health promotion in high risk regions of China will be crucial to prevent and control the A (H7N9) epidemic.

This analysis provides an integrated risk assessment framework for A (H7N9) epidemic potential in humans. The norther coastal province has the index-case potential for the relative humidity and temperature. The provinces in central China has the epidemic potential for the vulnerability and lack of capacity. The two-stage risk and its heterogeneity among provinces in mainland China detected in our study will be helpful for governments or health departments for proactively health preparedness. With the two-stage evaluation, the governments at-risk provinces should improve surveillance, diagnostic capabilities, and health promotion for the A (H7N9) transmission. The framework could also contribute to the proactive and quantitative risk assessment of other devastating pathogens.




Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.