Research Article: The Importance of Prions

Date Published: January 31, 2013

Publisher: Public Library of Science

Author(s): Glenn C. Telling, Heather True-Krob.


Partial Text

While agent host-range and strain properties convinced early researchers of a viral etiology, the once unorthodox postulate that prion transmission occurs by conformational corruption of host-encoded cellular prion protein (PrPC) by a pathogenic isoform (PrPSc) is now widely accepted. Indeed, conformational templating is increasingly understood to be a general mechanism of protein-mediated information transfer and pathogenesis. The high infectivity of prions, their capacity to cause neurodegeneration in genetically tractable animal models, as well as the ability to culture prions in cells, or under cell-free conditions using defined components, provide finely controlled experimental settings in which to elucidate general mechanisms for all diseases involving protein conformational templating, and thus to develop integrated therapeutic approaches.

Prion disease epidemics are frequent and, since they are invariably fatal and incurable, of significant concern for animal and human health. Examples include kuru, once the leading cause of death among the Fore people in Papua New Guinea, caused by mortuary feasting; the global bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) epidemic, and its subsequent zoonotic transmission in the form of variant Creutzfeldt Jakob disease (vCJD), caused by prion contamination of cattle and human food, respectively; and repeated examples of large-scale animal prion disease epidemics caused by contaminated animal vaccines. The etiologies of chronic wasting disease (CWD) of deer, elk, and moose, and transmissible mink encephalopathy as well, are less well understood. CWD is of particular concern because it is the only recognized prion disease of wild as well as captive animals. Its unparalleled transmission efficiency complicates strategies for controlling CWD, which continues to emerge in new locations and species.

The limited number of prion-susceptible PrPC-expressing cell lines and the ability to isolate subclones of such cells with variable susceptibilities to prion infection support the notion that unidentified auxiliary cellular factor(s) participate in prion replication. Recent studies characterizing the properties of prion strains that replicate in both the lymphoreticular and central nervous systems (CNS) underscore the involvement of tissue-specific factors. Using transgenic mice, Beringue and co-workers compared the ability of brain and spleen tissues to replicate CWD and BSE prions and found that interspecies transmission showed marked tissue dependence, with lymphoreticular tissue being consistently more permissive than brain [5]. The variability of prion strain properties from tissue to tissue within an infected host raises the possibility that assessments of zoonotic potential based on the properties of CNS-derived strains, rather than prions identified in tissues directly consumed by humans [6]–[8], may give rise to misleading estimates of human species barriers to animal prions.

The fundamental event during prion propagation is physicochemical conversion of predominantly α-helical, monomeric, protease-sensitive, and detergent-soluble PrPC into aggregation-prone, protease-resistant, detergent-insoluble PrPSc that is rich in β-sheet. Determining the mechanism by which this conformational transformation occurs remains a fundamental challenge, and key to this is an understanding of the high-resolution structures of both PrP isoforms. The three-dimensional structure of bacterially expressed recPrP is well characterized and consists of a largely unstructured amino-terminal region, while residues 126 to 218 in the carboxyl-terminus encompass a structured globular domain comprised of three α-helices interspersed with two short sections forming a β-pleated sheet. In contrast, little is known about the structural details of the infectious conformation. Recent experimental studies using mass spectrometry analysis coupled with hydrogen-deuterium exchange indicate a PrPSc conformation radically different from PrPC[13], which is at odds with the “β-helical” and “spiral” models, in which PrPSc retains substantial amounts of native α-helices [14], [15]. Undoubtedly, the capacity to amplify highly infectious prions using recPrP by PMCA [10] will greatly facilitate the isolation of PrPSc for future structural studies.

The participation of prions in diverse biological settings ranging from translation termination in yeast, memory in Aplysia, and antiviral innate immune responses has demonstrated the generality of protein-mediated information transfer [18]. Increasing evidence also links the prion mechanism to proteins involved in the pathogenesis of other common neurodegenerative diseases [19]. In the case of Alzheimer’s disease (AD), initial evidence of disease transmission to marmosets was confirmed by several groups in transgenic mouse models of AD using either brain homogenates from AD patients, or synthetic amyloid-β (Aβ peptides), even following peripheral inoculation [18], [19]. While early work in transgenic models suggested acceleration of a preexisting condition by inoculation, as was previously demonstrated for transgenic mouse models of an inherited form of human prion disease [20], that disease is truly transmissible was shown by induction of Aβ deposition following injection of AD brain extracts into animals that otherwise do not develop pathology [21]. Similar prion-like transmission has been demonstrated in various settings for other misfolded proteins involved in human neurodegenerative diseases, including the intracytoplasmic proteins tau, also involved in AD and various neurodegenerative diseases referred to as taopathies, and α-synuclein, the primary constituent of Lewy bodies found in Parkinson’s disease [18].

Prions offer significant advantages to address the mechanisms of selective neurodegeneration. First, in contrast to animal models of other human neurodegenerative diseases that may require overexpression of multiple mutant transgenes to incompletely mirror only certain features of pathogenesis, all aspects of human and animal prion diseases are recapitulated following their adaptive transmission to laboratory rodents, including early behavioral changes, profound neurodegeneration, and associated clinical deficits. Second, by transgenic manipulations of PrP genes in mice, it is possible to precisely modify responses to prion infections from a variety of human and animal sources and to model inherited forms of human prion disease [1]. Third, prions exist as different strains with defined and reproducible replication kinetics and neurotropic properties.




0 0 vote
Article Rating
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments